XO is very proud to have worked with nonprofits since the very first project many years ago. So we live in two worlds: on any given day we might be designing a digital platform for a corporate enterprise, and the next mapping out a brand strategy for a nonprofit.
Because we sit at this intersection, we’ve learned a few things about what it takes to be a good partner to nonprofits in particular. We receive a lot of new clients after another agency has somehow failed – and we hear the same story over and over. The previous firm was trying to drop a corporate playbook onto a nonprofit culture. They expect the same linear timelines, the same top-down sign-offs, and the same corporate definitions of success.
Now I don’t pretend to know how to run a nonprofit—that’s our clients’ expertise. But we do know how to design and build for them. Over years of collaborating on these initiatives, we’ve learned that getting a project to the finish line requires a completely different approach to two things: culture and stakeholders.
Designing for Consensus, Not Command
Nonprofit culture is inherently mission-driven and deeply collaborative. Staff members are often personally invested in the cause, which means they are fiercely protective of how the organization represents itself. They could work elsewhere, often for more pay, but they’re here. They care. If an agency tries to rush a brand refresh or a website overhaul through a single executive champion without engaging the broader team, the project will face walls of resistance later on. You may get through a meeting with good vibes, but if the recommendations and work isn’t adopted, did it actually succeed? I would say no. You have to get the entire organization, not just a leader, excited and aligned around the solutions you’re creating.
Takeaway
Respect the consensus-driven culture rather than fight it. For example:
- Better listening: We build intentional, structured workshops early in the project to capture input from staff and advocates who are on the front lines of the mission. We include draft work that we acknowledge isn’t really a recommendation, but it gives teams an easier way to give input by responding to something rather than just asking abstract questions.
- Facilitation over presentation: Don’t just “pitch” ideas; facilitate alignment. Success means making sure the team feels ownership over the direction.
Differences in Accountability
When we design a digital experience for a B2B enterprise, the target audience is fairly straightforward: the user.
With nonprofits, the target audience is a complex, overlapping web of stakeholders. When we design a digital platform or a brand strategy, we aren’t just building for one end-user; we are building something that must answer to a massive matrix of accountability.
- The Funders: The experience has to prove to institutional donors and individual givers that the organization is credible, transparent, and worthy of investment.
- The Board: A rotating group of passionate volunteers from diverse professional backgrounds who all have a say in the organization’s strategic direction.
- The Beneficiaries: The actual people or communities the nonprofit serves. The tools and brands we build must be accessible, dignified, and highly functional for them.
Because a nonprofit answers to so many different groups, two things can happen. One – a project can easily succumb to “scope creep” as everyone tries to satisfy every stakeholder at once. Our job as an agency partner isn’t to ignore this, but to help our clients navigate it. We act as the objective guardrails—using data, user research, and clear UX strategy to prioritize features so the final product serves the community without overwhelming the organization. The other thing that can happen is that quality can be traded for consensus. That’s bad. And it’s the agency’s job to prevent it from happening. When there are multiple stakeholders all wanting priority placement in a site or a campaign, we need to find solutions that allow for that broad communication need. But that doesn’t mean we just stuff things in places they shouldn’t go. It’s a balance to provide expertise that sometimes pushes back, but in the end helps the organization hit their goals. Good agencies with nonprofit experience know how to do this.
Takeaway
Serve as the guardrail, balancing diverse stakeholder needs without diluting the final product. For example:
- Strategic prioritization: Use user research and clear UX best practices to anchor decisions. This keeps the focus on the primary audience and prevents the project from succumbing to scope creep.
- Constructive pushback: Don’t just be an order-taker to please every faction. Protect quality by finding elegant communication solutions that hit the organization’s goals without cluttering the experience. It’s not always a creative exercise, this is also where best practices can come in. Other organizations have likely had similar challenges – how did they solve them? Showing case studies can help different stakeholders understand who should actually get priority in certain areas.
Enterprise rigor, with empathy.
Nonprofits don’t need external partners to come in and tell them on how to operate like a business. They already know their mission inside and out.
What they need are design and strategy partners who bring enterprise-grade technical skills and operational rigor, but leave the corporate culture at the door.
